ADVERTISEMENT
Close
In This Issue, Subscribe, Free Issue, Contact Us
ADVERTISEMENT
 
Nutrition and Weight Loss > Healthy Eating > Good Food > Fresh vs. Frozen Produce
Text Size Plus Minus | Print Email

Fresh vs. Frozen Produce

Which is best? Unless you're picking it yourself, the nutritional difference may not matter. Learn why.

By Sean Kelley

There's nothing quite like eating a handful of freshly picked blueberries on a warm summer day, each bite bursting with flavor and cancer-fighting antioxidants, bone-building minerals and must-have vitamins. Surprisingly, you can get nearly the same nutrition from a bag of frozen blueberries. Despite what you may have heard, fresh produce may not be more nutritious than frozen produce.

Even canned fruits and veggies are a good source of many of the nutrients found on the produce aisle of your grocery store, says Gene Lester, a U.S. Department of Agricultural plant physiologist who specializes in the nutritional content of plants and fruits.

"Nutrition is not always as straight forward as you'd like it to be," Lester says.

Many things factor into produce's nutritional makeup: When it's picked, the method of preservation – even the way a vegetable or fruit is prepared. The produce with the highest nutritional content is probably that which you've grown or picked yourself and eaten on the spot. But even that isn't completely clear.

For example, vegetables grown in sandy soil are up to five times less nutritional than those grown in clay soil. "If you had fresh produce from a farm that's just down the street, but the produce is grown on sandy soil, it might have less nutrients than produce sold at a grocery store," Lester says.

What keeps nutrients in preserved foods on par with fresh produce? Fresh fruits and veggies may be picked before they reach their nutritional peak, so that they can ripen while in transit. In contrast, frozen fruits and vegetables are often picked at a more mature state and then flash frozen. Canned vegetables go through a similar process, sealing in many nutrients.

Still, the preservations methods are not without their drawbacks. Some important nutrients like B vitamins and vitamin C are water-soluble; in canned goods, those vitamins will leach into water the produce is packed in. Exposure to air and light – either in your fridge or in a fruit bowl on your kitchen counter – can also limit the shelf life of some vitamins.

But other nutrients – including vitamins A, D, E and K, and fiber – survive this process.

The important thing, Lester says, is to eat more vegetables and fruit, whether they’re canned, frozen or fresh. "The more mouthfuls of vegetables you eat, the less mouthfuls of fattier foods you'll eat," he says.

Ruth
12 May 2011, 14:46
Thanks for this article. As the last poster stated, it seems that many folks missed the point. And for those who asked for % differences . . . well, one of the points of the article was that there are a lot of variables that affect nutrition! To give a % difference between fresh and nonfresh, one would need to know about growing conditions, picking times, packing & transport aspects, etc.

I think many of us always feel that fresh is best. Thanks for pointing out that that's not always the case.
JIm Barber
12 May 2011, 11:54
Sean,

I do believe some people missed the point of your article which was to tell us that eating canned and frozen vegetables is not a bad thing to do. I feel that an in depth scientific discussion would be beyond the scope of this article.

Years ago I had been subscribed to a nutrition action newsletter that was a good source for finding out some of the information that a few of the respondants were looking for.

Thank you for taking the time and effort to pass on this information. It makes me feel better about eating canned and frozen vegetables.

JB
Deb
12 May 2011, 10:02
This article makes a lot of great points and will help me make healthier choices on a broad scale. THANKS SO MUCH! It's nice to have other options when something isn't available "fresh" at the time; this article helps me feel better about buying something frozen or in a can - I had thought that freezing food in particular would destroy a LOT of the nutritional value. I agree with the other posters, too... you have to watch out for the added salt & sugar in processed foods. HAVE A GREAT DAY!
Annette
09 May 2011, 21:41
No mention of sodium and sugar in processed foods. I would like to know a little more of what foods I should stay away from.
Nikki McMillan
27 Apr 2011, 22:20
I like fresh fruits the best. They have the best flavor.
D. Leatherman
20 Apr 2011, 16:38
This article is stating, quite simply, that there is not one correct answer. So if you eat all types then you will have yourself covered.
Elizabeth
20 Apr 2011, 07:16
If that article is not beating around the bush and saying nothing, I don't know what is. You never really answered anything. you did say the vitamins B & C are water soluble. You never mentioned the exact difference of the % of vitamins lost or gained between the fresh and frozen fruit.. I like the exact facts and you never got to it.....
A. Brennan
19 Apr 2011, 10:29
No mention of added Sodium or Sugar in the processed foods.

Leave a Comment

The comment function provides the opportunity to comment on the content above.

General comments or questions to Arthritis Today editors and medical experts can be submitted here. Past medical questions and answers are available here.

Promotion of products and services and other inappropriate comments are prohibited and will be removed. If you spot one of these before we do, please send an alert.

All fields are required but only your name and comment will be displayed. Your e-mail address will not be used for any other purpose.

Name:
Email:
Text:

ADVERTISEMENT
Arthritis Foundation National Health Council BBB Accredited Charity