ADVERTISEMENT
Close
In This Issue, Subscribe, Free Issue, Contact Us
ADVERTISEMENT
 
Fitness > Yoga and Tai Chi > Top 10 Yoga Myths Debunked
Text Size Plus Minus | Print Email

Top 10 Yoga Myths Debunked

You can’t do yoga if you have arthritis. Yoga’s too gentle to have real health benefits. You’ll have to get fit before you start yoga. There are many myths about yoga – we set out to debunk a few.

By Susan Bernstein

People with arthritis, who need regular physical activity to keep joints flexible, maintain muscle tone and manage weight, may find yoga a perfect way to exercise. The gentle, flowing poses can be less stressful on sore joints than other types of movement.

In fact, some studies show that yoga, which has its roots in ancient India, can reduce arthritis-related pain, improve joint function, build strength and promote relaxation. “It’s low impact,” says Janice Kiecolt-Glaser, PhD, a professor at The Ohio State University in Columbus who conducted recent research on possible physical benefits of yoga. “It has a lot of potential benefits. Doing [yoga] every day would be wonderful, but a couple of times a week would be easy to expect.”

Participating in yoga – usually referred to as practicing yoga – involves moving into a series of poses, and often includes breathing and relaxation exercises. However, there is no one single method. Yoga is a actually an umbrella term that covers hundreds of variations.

Yoga Myths Abound

There are almost as many myths and misconceptions about yoga as there are types. That isn’t surprising for an activity that’s been around some 5,000 years. However, it can be daunting for someone who’s looking to get started – especially someone with arthritis.

We set out to identify and put to rest some common myths about yoga and practicing yoga with arthritis.

Myth: Yoga involves so much twisting and bending – it’s going to make my arthritis worse, not better.

Fact: Many styles of yoga, including Iyengar yoga, include gentle, flowing movements and allow you to use a chair or other prop to aid balance. These forms of yoga are safe for someone with arthritis.

Myth: Yoga all about burning incense and chanting ohm.

Fact: Yoga is a popular form of exercise and relaxation for Americans of all ages. A 2008 survey by Yoga Journal found that 15.8 million people nationwide practice yoga. Some yoga classes may involve meditation or chanting, along with burning candles or incense, but the majority are more like gentle exercise classes.

Myth: Yoga is too gentle to have any physical benefits. It’s more about chilling out than getting fit.

Fact: Yoga is gentle and less stressful on joints, but studies show it offers both physical and psychological benefits. Practicing yoga regularly can improve muscle strength and joint flexibility, while boosting mood and controlling stress. Some forms of yoga involve quickly moving from pose to pose and count as a light cardiovascular exercise. With regular practice, you can build up strength and flexibility, and try faster motions or more weight-bearing moves.

Page 1 | 2

Marilyn
09 Nov 2011, 14:51
Im 62, I have had arthritis for quite some time along with other problems, I was in PT and they turned around and said I couldnt do that because of other health issues, so I went home found a good yoga tape on netflix and started that. this was months ago, today I am pretty much painfree as long as I continue using it. something like half an hour in the am and im good for the day. Doctors were talking about how bad I was, I needed surgery and meds and so on, they were handing me big bottles of painkillers that I wouldnt take. One doctor encouraged me trying the yoga, he was the one that said I could not continue the PT. He was right, the pain meds and other stuff the other doctors came up with were not necessary I can move freely now, I couldnt even sit up or dress without terrible pain prior to this.
Melanie
28 Oct 2011, 15:16
I did yoga at a gym once a week for nearly 3 years and then joined a yoga studio. That was nearly tree years ago. It's been incredible. I have severe psoriatic arthritis and it has helped my range of motion more than physical therapy. It has also helped me emotionally and spiritually. It calms my mind after an active day as a teacher. Yes, I do power classes, but back off and do gentle classes when I need to. The yoginis have been wonderful in keeping an eye on me and modifying asanas when needed. I would recommend it for anyone with arthritis.
Kev Richards
24 Oct 2011, 10:35
I do a combination of Tai Chi (Qigong) and Yoga - starting with the Tai Chi and that definitely keeps my joints from getting stiff. Beginners yoga is of course gentle - but advanced yoga is not! But if you can do advanced yoga you don't have any problems. :)

I started to get knee problems when I STOPPED my yoga tai chi routines while working in those damned unhealthy offices. I recovered as soon as I started again - it takes a month or so to start to recover.
Peggy
18 Oct 2011, 18:29
Thanks for all the posts. I have RA, diagnosed a few months ago. I am going to try Yoga asap!
Patricia W
17 Oct 2011, 17:24
I'm 64 and have had RA for 35 years I've been practing Yoga for the past 15 yrs and find not only relaxing, but strength building too. The gentle stretching help with the daily aches and pains. With all the modifications that are able to be practiced with the postures there are no postures one cannot do.
P.J. Thomson
15 Oct 2011, 19:07
I would like to get the name of a good chair yoga DVD or Video to purchase to try to help my degenerative arthritis and osteoarthritis. If someone has some suggestions please email me with the information.

Thank you,

PJ :0)
MaryEllen S
15 Oct 2011, 18:03
I have had JRA since 2 1/2 yrs of age. I'm 58 now. Obviously, my life is quite complicated and I have most of my joints affected with JRA and/or OA and Osteoporousis. I do chair yoga faithfully. It helps me with my flexibilituy, pain management, balance, stamina, breathing, etc. As I go on, I'm getting better at it. Exercise is so important and chair yoga is one of my main resources. DO IT TODAY!!!
Faisuly lópez
14 Oct 2011, 11:28
I dont speak englih, but I would like practices yoga. How can I do??

I have a fibromialgia; my pain is very hard, if yours can I help....

sorry for my poor english.

Bye
Kay Jay Emme
14 Oct 2011, 09:35
But it is so horribly, horribly boring. I cannot get past that.
Eleanor Evans
12 Oct 2011, 19:45
I have been practicing Beginner's Yoga for just 1 yr. I am 71 yrs old. I wish I would have started it many years ago. I have lots of "arthur", knee, lower back and all my fingers. I truly enjoy the varied classes I take usually 3 times a week. It should be a crime to feel as good as I do post yoga class!!
Arden Martos
12 Oct 2011, 14:48
I wanted to send this to my husband, who had been laboring under some of the misperceptions you debunk here. But you threw up one after another of these scrambled letter scenarios. After I had don 3 - 4, and you sent up another, I said, to heck with this! This is not the way to win friends and influence people!
Colette Cecchini
12 Oct 2011, 12:09
I do something called "yoga chair" I like it a lot and it is very heelpful for my RA.
Noreen Braman
12 Oct 2011, 10:13
As a certified Laughter Yoga leader and humor presenter, I heartily reccomend laughter yoga and humor presentations to anyone who has any kind of pain. As popularized by Norman Cousins, and later verified by scientific studies, laughter truly provides pain relief. In laughter yoga it is all about laughter and yogic breathing. One learns to "laugh for no reason" in order to gain both the physical and psychological benefits of laughter. As a person with fibromyalgia and OA, I can personally attest to how it helps!
Linda M.
12 Oct 2011, 09:52
I am 66, and my OA Began with pain in my neck, hands and wrists. I have taken yoga classes 3-4 times a week for over 10 years and am amazed that none of my symptoms have worsened in all that time. I have virtually no neck pain now. My back is strong and flexible. I can hike for miles on rough trails and sleep very well. Yoga is the best exercise I have ever experienced, but my practice has improved by doing simple weight classes as well to improve muscle strength.
Pam V
12 Oct 2011, 09:39
As a sufferer of both RA and OA I recommend yoga. Most yoga classes are about gently stretching your muscles and they usually talk about intent. If you feel uncomfortable you don't do it. Instructors are there to help you do it right not push you to do too much. Some people can bend over and barely touch their toes while others can easily touch the floor with palms down. Either way is correct it’s about what is good for you. YMCA classes stress flexibility and stress relief. You can make it a religious experience if you like but it’s not taught that way at the Y. Flexibility is the key to an active older age! That is what I’m looking for. I do sometimes have limitation with my hands and knees, if it hurts I do it very gently or not at all. I can say it’s never made me feel worse only better!

Leave a Comment

The comment function provides the opportunity to comment on the content above.

General comments or questions to Arthritis Today editors and medical experts can be submitted here. Past medical questions and answers are available here.

Promotion of products and services and other inappropriate comments are prohibited and will be removed. If you spot one of these before we do, please send an alert.

All fields are required but only your name and comment will be displayed. Your e-mail address will not be used for any other purpose.

Name:
Email:
Text:

ADVERTISEMENT
Arthritis Foundation National Health Council BBB Accredited Charity