ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement
ADVERTISEMENT
 
Community > Expert Q & A > Osteoarthritis > Do Magnets Help Osteoarthritis?
Text Size   Plus   Minus   |   Print   |   Email  

Do Magnets Help Osteoarthritis?

Q: I have heard of arthritis magnets or healing magnets that relieve osteoarthritis pain. Is there scientific evidence that sleeping on a magnet-filled mattress pad will help with OA pain?

A: One very small study has suggested a magnet-filled mattress pad would help, but this would need to be replicated before I would recommend you pursue this therapy. Another study, conducted by Harvard University researchers on people with knee OA, found that those who wore a sleeve containing a high-powered magnet over the affected knee reported greater pain relief after four hours than those wearing a placebo knee sleeve.

For the most part, however, studies of arthritis magnets or “healing magnets” for osteoarthritis pain have been inconclusive. In 2007, an analysis by British researchers of 29 studies of static magnets suggested there was no significant difference in pain reduction between people using magnets and placebo. The authors, who published their findings in the Canadian Medical Association Journal, concluded: “For osteoarthritis, the evidence is insufficient to exclude a clinically important benefit, which creates an opportunity for further investigation.”

My suggestion would be to consider purchasing a magnet to wear over the area of the body where you need pain relief before making a more substantive investment in a magnetic mattress pad.

Daniel Clauw, MD, Rheumatologist

Janice
01 Jun 2010, 15:17
I am a NIKKEN Independent Distributor. I was looking for something for low back pain (Spondilylicysis) wrong spelling, Knee Pain, and right ankle pain. I wear a magnetic pearl necklace, a large magnetic back pad, magnetic shoe pads, smaller knee magnets, sleep on a magnetic mattress pad and magnetic pillow. Without these magnetic products I would not still be walking, sitting and working everyday. I have no disks between my vertebra, have vertebra which have slipped, have narrowing of the spinal column. I need spinal surgery and knee surgery which I cannot afford. I don't want to take strong pain killers because they weaken the body. Email me if you are interested.
Lisa
18 May 2010, 23:34
I have not tried magnetic therapy but I can tell you that I have had significant pain relief and decreased swelling from my RA as well pain relief from tight painful muscles (Fibromyalgia)by using a blanket infused with ceramic particles.

I got this product online at Back on Track. They have human products as well as horse and dog products.

I am going to order some of the clothing and in particular the gloves to decrease my hand pain and inflamation.

Hope this helps someone!
David Yoches
15 Apr 2010, 10:19
Low Level Laser Therapy...

I have been using a low level laser device that is FDA approved for over-the-counter use for pain management of OA of the hand. I'm using it on my knee and foot finding that it does provide pain relief.

David Yoches
Debbie
16 Mar 2010, 14:01
I tried magnets on my knees did not get any relief.
Sally
25 Oct 2009, 21:19
Magnetic bracelets:
I have OA in my hands and the thumb joint is the worst affected area. Last December I bought two magnetic bracelets from a local crafter who makes them exclusively. I was very sceptical but was willing to try them to avoid going on harsh medications. I have had significant relief while wearing them and now leave them on 24 hrs a day. I still have some pain but it is much, much less than before.
James Khoo
11 Sep 2009, 08:33
I have a right arthritic hip joint, while feels stiff and painful when I walk. I had stopped all alcoholic drinks for a good 10 years. A short while ago on a special dinner I ventured to try a glass of red wine, a Merlot. Surprisingly upon getting up from bed the following morning, the stiffiness and pain disappeared. I believe either the alcohol improves the blood circulation in the joint or helps to cut down the inflamation. And I have read in medical journal that advises us to avoid alcohol when we have arthritis. Can anyone please provide me with som input on this issue?
Brenda - Minneapolis
25 Aug 2009, 18:35
I started out just making jewelry with crystal, stone etc. etc.... and selling them at local craft shows. Due to repeated requests from shoppers about where they could buy magnetic jewelry, I started buying first hematite and switched to magnatite beads and putting together bracelets, anklets and necklaces. Much to my surprise these items have become the main selling items at all my shows. I have people who buy from me over and over swearing the magnetics help relieve their pain. Two customers swear it helps their fibromyalgia. Numerous people swear it helps their arthritis, both osteo and rheumatoid. One person found relief from the pain caused by a bunion. Because I suffer from a huge bunion on my left foot, I went home and immediately made myself a magnetic anklet and within 3 days the pain was definitely less. The anklet is actually bigger now that when I made it and my new shoes don't hurt like they did. To me that means it helped decrease the swelling in my foot. Some people do not get any relief from magnets and with some people the help is so subtle they don't notice a difference until they quit wearing the pieces.
cliff
22 Aug 2009, 06:25
My Mom used to wear a copper braclet to help with her OA pain. She never seemed to have the pain when she wore it. does anyone know anything about it.
Ross
20 Aug 2009, 23:39
Brother! If this voodoo stuff worked, wouldn't someone have noticed that those who work in environments that have a high Gauss level, such as a radio room or military aircraft with a lot of electromagnetic gear or the generator room at the base of a dam somewhere never suffered from arthritic type pains or that perhaps there was a lower level of same? I guess if you believe in something enough the good old placebo effect may kick in, but I have been exposed to high levels of electromagnetism and high Gauss environments for years, along with others that had no presumption that this was efficacious, and I never noticed the slightest relief from my significant arthritis pain; I sure wish I had!
Charlene
19 Aug 2009, 10:03
I read the text from Cynthia Olson about her
bracelet that a friend gave her that took her
shoulder pain away. I sure can use that. Where can you buy one and what kind do you buy? I spend a lot of time sleeping in my recliner in order to get any sleep. Would like to hear from someone.

Thank You, Charlene
Diana
19 Aug 2009, 07:50
My husband has OA and fibromylgia, if I thought this would help him I would try it .Does anyone have any input into this?
Diane
18 Aug 2009, 13:35
I slept on a magnetic mattress for over four months. I did not feel any relief for the pain. However, some of my friends felt noticeable relief.
Phyllis
18 Aug 2009, 10:26
I have osteoarthritis (fortunately fairly mild so far)and what works best for my right wrist is a magnetic bracelet. However a magnetic knee cuff does not work for my left knee. My lower back is improved with magnets taped to it, but as above, they are difficult to keep on.
Jenny
18 Aug 2009, 09:13
The placebo effect is a wonderful thing sometimes. Whatever helps is good.
cynthia olson
03 Aug 2009, 08:23
A couple of months ago my friend gave me a decorative bracelet of magnets that wraps around my wrist. She did not know I was having shoulder problems. I recall after wearing it all day (because the colors looked really nice with what I was wearing). I noticed that I did not have any shoulder pain that night so I wore it the next day and again I noticed no pain. I then didn't wear it for several days and started having pain again. Last night I got up a 1:00 in the morning because of the amount of pain I was having. I put the bracelet on and slept with it and slept through the entire night with no pain in the morning. I don't know how this works but I know there is something to it.
Marcia
23 Jun 2009, 12:54
I sleep on a magnetic mattress pad. I've tried taking it off to test the difference. Keeping it on all the time is much better!
Don't expect miracles. Any difference is an improvement.
I use a magnetic cuff when the arm/ hand hurts, especially after a long day at work using the computer.
Now I'm looking for something that would fit my fat knees.
Magnets do work. Try to cut something strong like the hard plastic covering over a safety store product or produce container. Then put on a magnetic cuff or step on a magnetic shoe insert. The cutting is suddenly possible again! :-)
Emilie
11 Jun 2009, 18:54
I tried using a variety of magnets that I would tape to the painful spot on my body. I had either very inconclusive results or some relief. They were hard to keep on.
Cason
06 Apr 2009, 19:17

Magnet matress:
My wife has to sleep on a magnet matress about four nights per week, no more than 7-8 hrs. per night, to get relief in her back and hips. This does nothing for me and won't help all people, but it does get her relief for a good night sleep. She alsodoes a lot of exercises, and uses a tilt table, but her system just won't take most arthritic medations.
Thank you Cason

Leave a Comment

The comment function provides the opportunity to comment on the content above.

General comments or questions to Arthritis Today editors and medical experts can be submitted here. Past medical questions and answers are available here.

Promotion of products and services and other inappropriate comments are prohibited and will be removed. If you spot one of these before we do, please send an alert.

All fields are required but only your name and comment will be displayed. Your e-mail address will not be used for any other purpose.

Name:
Email:
Text:

ADVERTISEMENT
Advertisement